Skip to content

Enter delivery address

The Ice Cream Shop

x Delivery unavailable 653 Montauk Highway, NY 11954

Ice Cream

Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream, Chocolate-Vanilla (16 oz)
16 oz
Quick view
$10.99
Breyers Natural Ice Cream, Vanilla (47.67 oz)
47.67 oz
Quick view
$5.99
Reese's Peanut Butter King Size Cream Bar (3.85 fl oz)
3.85 fl oz
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's The Tonight Dough Ice Cream, Chocolate-Caramel-Peanut Butter (473 ml)
473 ml
Quick view
$9.99
Breyers Ice Cream, Vanilla-Chocolate-Strawberry (1.5 qt)
1.5 qt
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Chocolate Fudge Brownie (1 lbs)
1 lbs

Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Phish Food Chocolate Ice Cream With Marshmallow (16 fl oz)
16 fl oz
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Stephen Colbert's Vanilla Ice Cream, Americone Dream (16.68 oz)
16.68 oz
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Chocolate Chip (473 ml)
473 ml
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream, Churray For Churros (1 pint)
1 pint
Quick view
$10.99
Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Ice Cream, Milk & Cookies (16.7 oz)
16.7 oz
Quick view
$10.99
Ben & Jerry's Netflix and Chilll'd Ice Cream, Peanut Butter (16 oz)
16 oz

Quick view
$10.99
Ben & Jerry's Vermont's Finest Ice Cream, Strawberry-Cheesecake (473 ml)
473 ml
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Topped Ice Cream, Raspberry Cheesecake (15.2 fl oz)
15.2 fl oz
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Vermont's Finest Ice Cream, Cherry Garcia (16 fl oz)
16 fl oz

Sweet Treats

Quick view
$3.00
Semi Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie 6 Pack
Quick view
$5.49
Nerds Gummy Clusters Candy (5 oz)
5 oz
Quick view
$2.00
Reese's Milk Chocolate Cups Candy, Peanut Butter (2.8 oz, 4 ct)
2.8 oz
Quick view
$3.99
Chips Ahoy! Original Chocolate Chip Cookies, king (0.38 oz, 10 ct)
3.75 oz
Quick view
$9.39
KitKat Unwrapped Minis Crisp Wafers Milk Chocolate (7.6 oz)
7.6 oz
Quick view
$3.00
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookie 6 Pack

Quick view
$5.59
Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers Gummi Candy, Assorted Flavors (7.2 oz)
7.2 oz
Quick view
$4.99
Gushers Super Sour Fruit Snacks, Berry (4.25 oz)
4.25 oz
Quick view
$3.99
Keebler Fudge Stripe King Size 4.75oz
Quick view
$3.99
Reese's Fast Break Candy Bar, Milk Chocolate-Peanut Butter (3.5 oz)
3.5 oz
Quick view
$3.00
Sugar Cookie 6 Pack
Quick view
$5.49
Airheads Xtremes Rainbow Berry Bites Candy (6 oz)
6 oz

Quick view
$1.00
Nature Valley Sweet & Salty Granola Bar, Peanut (1.2 oz)
1.2 oz
Quick view
$2.99
Oreo Sandwich Cookies, Chocolate (2.4 oz, 6 ct)
2.4 oz
Quick view
$4.39
Reese's Sticks Milk Chocolate Wafer Candy, Peanut Butter, King (0.75 oz, 4 ct)
3 oz

Best sellers

Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream, Chocolate-Vanilla (16 oz)
16 oz
Quick view
$3.00
Semi Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie 6 Pack
Quick view
$5.49
Nerds Gummy Clusters Candy (5 oz)
5 oz
Quick view
$4.99
Gatorade Cool Blue 28oz
28 fl oz
Quick view
$7.99
Nutella Hazelnut Spread With Cocoa (13 oz)
13 oz
Quick view
$3.99
Fruit by the Foot Fruit Flavored Snacks, Berry Tie-Dye (3 oz, 4 ct)
3 oz

Quick view
$3.99
Chips Ahoy! Original Chocolate Chip Cookies, king (0.38 oz, 10 ct)
3.75 oz
Quick view
$5.59
Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers Gummi Candy, Assorted Flavors (7.2 oz)
7.2 oz
Quick view
$10.99
Breyers Natural Ice Cream, Vanilla (47.67 oz)
47.67 oz
Quick view
$3.49
Coca-Cola Original Soda (16 fl oz)
16 fl oz
Quick view
$4.29
Skyra Icelandic Spring Water (33.8 fl oz)
33.8 fl oz
Quick view
$3.00
Red Velvet Cookie 6 Pack

Quick view
$2.00
Reese's Milk Chocolate Cups Candy, Peanut Butter (2.8 oz, 4 ct)
2.8 oz
Quick view
$9.99
Ben & Jerry's The Tonight Dough Ice Cream, Chocolate-Caramel-Peanut Butter (473 ml)
473 ml
Quick view
$3.99
Canada Dry Soda (20 fl oz)
20 fl oz

Javascript disabled

Javascript disabled

Javascript is needed to run Postmates. You can try enabling it or visiting the website with a browser that supports Javascript.