Skip to content

Enter delivery address

The Ice Cream Shop

137 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454

Sundae Prep

Quick view
$2.59
24/7 Life Cutlery Assortment All Purpose 24 Count
Quick view
$4.59
Kraft Jet-Puffed Marshmallows (16 oz)
16 oz
Quick view
$7.09
Hershey's Genuine Syrup, Chocolate (24 oz)
24 oz
Quick view
$3.99
24/7 Life Paper Bowls 18 Count
Quick view
$6.09
Nutella Hazelnut Spread With Cocoa (13 oz)
13 oz

Best Sellers

Quick view
$4.19
Nerds Gummy Clusters Candy (5 oz)
5 oz
Quick view
$7.49
Ben & Jerry's Stephen Colbert's Vanilla Ice Cream, Americone Dream (16.68 oz)
16.68 oz
Quick view
$3.99
Coca-Cola Classic Soda Drink (20 fl oz)
20 fl oz
Quick view
$3.29
Snickers Peanuts Caramel Candy Bar, Milk Chocolate (1.86 oz)
1.86 oz
Quick view
$2.39
AriZona Green Tea With Ginseng and Honey (22 fl oz)
22 fl oz
Quick view
$4.09
Hershey's King Chocolate, Cookies-Cream (2.6 oz)
2.6 oz

Quick view
$4.09
Skyra Icelandic Spring Water (33.8 fl oz)
33.8 fl oz
Quick view
$3.39
Canada Dry Soda (20 fl oz)
20 fl oz
Quick view
$3.79
Monster Energy Energy Zero Ultra (16 fl oz)
16 fl oz
Quick view
$3.99
Gatorade Thirst Quencher Sports Drink, Lemon-Lime (28 fl oz)
28 fl oz
Quick view
$3.29
M&M's Peanut Chocolate Candy Pouches (1.74 oz, 48 ct)
1.74 oz
Quick view
$7.49
Ben & Jerry's Half Baked Ice Cream, Chocolate-Vanilla (16 oz)
16 oz

Quick view
$3.99
Sprite 20oz
20 fl oz
Quick view
$3.79
Monster Energy Original Energy Drink (16 fl oz)
16 fl oz
Quick view
$4.39
Smartwater 1L
1 L

Sweet Treats

Quick view
$4.09
Butterfinger King Size 3.7oz
Quick view
$4.19
Nerds Gummy Clusters Candy (5 oz)
5 oz
Quick view
$2.89
Chips Ahoy! Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies (3 oz)
3 oz
Quick view
$2.89
Nutella & Go! Hazelnut Spread + Breadsticks (1.8 oz)
1.8 oz
Quick view
$4.09
Reese's Big Peanut Butter Cup Milk Chocolate (2.8 oz, 2 ct)
2.8 oz
Quick view
$3.59
Skittles Original Share Size (4 oz)
4 oz

Quick view
$2.89
Chips Ahoy! Mini Chewy Cookies (3 oz)
3 oz
Quick view
$2.19
Nature Valley Crunchy Granola Bar, Oats ‘n Honey 1.5oz
Quick view
$4.39
Reese's Dipped Animal Crackers (4.25 oz)
4.25 oz
Quick view
$4.09
Reese's Sticks Milk Chocolate Wafer Candy, Peanut Butter, King (0.75 oz, 4 ct)
3 oz
Quick view
$4.39
Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers Gummi Candy, Fruit Punch (7.2 oz)
7.2 oz
Quick view
$4.09
Hershey's King Chocolate, Cookies-Cream (2.6 oz)
2.6 oz

Quick view
$4.89
Sour Patch Kids Soft & Chewy Candy, Watermelon (8 oz)
8 oz
Quick view
$2.59
Daelmans Caramel Stroopwafels (2.75 oz)
2.75 oz
Quick view
$4.09
Twix Caramel Chocolate Cookie Bar (3.02 oz, 4 ct)
3.02 oz

Javascript disabled

Javascript disabled

Javascript is needed to run Postmates. You can try enabling it or visiting the website with a browser that supports Javascript.