Lemon Meringue Pie Delivery in Bay Shore • Postmates

Our Little Italy

2 Offers Available

Our Little Italy

40–60 min

•

$0 Delivery Fee

• $

4.7

Intermezzo Brick Oven Trattoria

Top Offer • 20% off (Spend $25)

Intermezzo Brick Oven Trattoria

65–80 min

4.8

The International Delight Cafe

65–80 min

4.8

Crazy Crepe Cafe - Smithtown

2 Offers Available

Crazy Crepe Cafe - Smithtown

55–70 min

• $$

4.6

The Pizzeria of Islip

20–35 min

4.7

Umberto's of Lake Grove

70–85 min

• $

4.7

Tender Box (5012 Express Drive South)

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Tender Box (5012 Express Drive South)

50–65 min

• $$

3.5

Croxley's Ale House - Farmingdale

55–70 min

• $$

4.5

Flora's Pizza Cafe

70–85 min

4.8

Sapore Fino

65–80 min

• $$

4.3

Ditch Kitchen & Surf Bar

15–30 min

4.4

317 Main Street

55–70 min

• $$

4.5

Orlando's Deli of Bethpage

60–75 min

• $

4.8

Harleys American Grille

60–75 min

• $$

4.3

Union Blvd Deli

15–30 min

• $

4.5

Simply Greek Express

40–55 min

4.6

Jersey Mike's Subs (585 Main Street - Montauk Highway)

$0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

Jersey Mike's Subs (585 Main Street - Montauk Highway)

10–25 min

• $

4.6

Popei's - Coram

65–80 min

• $$

4.4

The Pie at Salvatores

10–25 min

4.8

Francesca’s Pizza

60–75 min

• $

4.5

Krisch's Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlour

50–65 min

4.2

Dunkin' (529 E. Main St)

2 Offers Available

Dunkin' (529 E. Main St)

10–20 min

• $

4.4

KC's Pizza N Wings (Islip)

35–50 min

3.9

Mongo's Coffee Roastery & Lounge

65–80 min

• $

4.6

Edesia Restaurant & Pizzeria

40–55 min

• $

4.6

Candlelight Diner Restaurant

40–55 min

• $

4.8

EMF Gourmet Italian Market

50–65 min

New

O Sole Mio

65–80 min

• $$

4.6

Bagel Chalet (Commack)

2 Offers Available

Bagel Chalet (Commack)

40–55 min

• $

4.8

Wendy's (168 Main Street)

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Wendy's (168 Main Street)

10–25 min

• $

4.4

Zorn's of Bethpage

60–75 min

• $

4.8

The dirty cheesecake by Lili

2 Offers Available

The dirty cheesecake by Lili

50–65 min

4.6

California Diner

45–60 min

• $

4.6

IHOP (Sunrise Hwy)

2 Offers Available

IHOP (Sunrise Hwy)

20–35 min

• $

4.4

KFC - Deer Park

Free Item (Spend $10)

KFC - Deer Park

25–40 min

• $$

4.5

NutriWolf - Deer Park

30–45 min

• $

4.9

Pierogibites & More

65–80 min

4.7

Carvel (1163 Deer Park Ave)

20–35 min

• $

4.8

Goody Two Shoes

10–25 min

4.4

Wheatley Deli(10 Colonial Springs Rd)

40–55 min

4.8

Ruvo Restaurant - Greenlawn

70–85 min

• $$$

4.7

Piccolo Ristorante

Top Offer • 30% off (Spend $25)

Piccolo Ristorante

70–85 min

• $

4.5

Rudi's

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Rudi's

55–70 min

• $$

4.6

Nino's Pizzeria Pasta & Heros

Free Item (Spend $30)

Nino's Pizzeria Pasta & Heros

60–75 min

4.6

Vinnies Mulberry Street Pizzeria

20–35 min

• $

4.7

Pastrami Express

60–75 min

• $

4.7

Chicken Tonight

35–50 min

• $

4.3

Arooga's Grille House & Sports Bar (Patchouge)

Top Offer • Spend $35, Save $10

Arooga's Grille House & Sports Bar (Patchouge)

60–75 min

• $

4.5

Infinity Diner

30–45 min

• $$

4.7

Doctor Cuisine

40–55 min

4.6

N'Meli Greek Grill

45–60 min

4.7

Satelite Pizza & Catering

Spend $50, Save $4

Satelite Pizza & Catering

50–65 min

4.6

Angela's Pizza

Free Item (Spend $30)

Angela's Pizza

25–40 min

4.7

The Penny Pub

15–30 min

• $

4.6

Tim Horton's (700 Motor Pkwy)

2 Offers Available

Tim Horton's (700 Motor Pkwy)

30–45 min

• $$

3.9

D & D Bakery

40–55 min

• $$

4.0

Coram diner

60–75 min

4.6

Greek Cove - East Norwich

60–75 min

• $

4.8

GTO

2 Offers Available

GTO

70–85 min

4.3

Red Lobster (1700 The Arches Circle)

35–50 min

• $$

4.5

Hauppauge Palace Diner

50–65 min

• $$

4.6

Terrace Diner

25–40 min

4.7

Tap Room (Bayshore)

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Tap Room (Bayshore)

20–35 min

• $

4.6

Arthur Treacher’s (2713 Merrick Road )

Free Item (Spend $20)

Arthur Treacher’s (2713 Merrick Road )

65–80 min

• $

New

Dang BBQ

65–80 min

4.5

Mias Ice cream Kitchen

55–70 min

4.8

Pita House

65–80 min

• $

4.3

Cold Stone Creamery (2350 Middle Country Rd)

65–80 min

• $

4.5

Lindenhurst Diner

35–50 min

• $$

4.6

Embassy Diner

65–80 min

4.6

The Village Idiot Pub - Patchogue

55–70 min

• $

4.4

Long Island Coffee Company

2 Offers Available

Long Island Coffee Company

60–75 min

• $

4.2

Milano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

50–65 min

4.7

Gino's of Lindenhurst Pizzeria & Restaurant

40–55 min

• $

4.7

BLD's Restaurant

45–60 min

• $$

4.5

Pasta Time Deli

70–85 min

New

Pigs On A Wing

Spend $15, Save $3

Pigs On A Wing

30–45 min

4.5

Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

10–25 min

4.6

Nunzi's

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Nunzi's

55–70 min

4.5

Holbrook Market Place and Delicatessen

45–60 min

4.8

Benkert's Bakery

65–80 min

• $

4.8

Umbertos of Wantagh

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Umbertos of Wantagh

70–85 min

4.7

Restaurant Depot (1335 Lakeland Avenue)

55–75 min

• $$

4.5

Mr. Sausage

70–85 min

• $$

4.8

Fireside Caterers (120 W Jericho Tpke Huntington Station)

Free Item (Spend $15)

Fireside Caterers (120 W Jericho Tpke Huntington Station)

60–75 min

4.5

Mazadar Grill & Catering

3 Offers Available

Mazadar Grill & Catering

10–25 min

New

Mary's Pizza and Pasta (Connetquot )

Top Offer • Spend $20, Save $5

Mary's Pizza and Pasta (Connetquot )

30–45 min

4.8

East Bay Diner

60–75 min

4.4

Mangiamo Market

60–75 min

4.7

Belfast Gastro Pub

35–50 min

4.5

Northside Delicatessen & Gourmet Catering

60–75 min

• $

4.8

BeeBeeZ Burgers and Wings - West Islip

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

BeeBeeZ Burgers and Wings - West Islip

20–35 min

4.3

Dragos Pizza

65–80 min

4.5

Lily's - Babylon

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Lily's - Babylon

30–45 min

• $$

4.4

Mile High Wings - Commack

45–60 min

4.2

Outback Steakhouse (612 WellWood Avenue)

Top Offer • Spend $25, Save $5

Outback Steakhouse (612 WellWood Avenue)

35–50 min

• $

4.4

Mannino's Italian Kitchen and Lounge

40–55 min

• $

4.6

Sbarro (1701 Sunrise Highway)

Top Offer • Spend $25, Save $7

Sbarro (1701 Sunrise Highway)

25–40 min

• $

4.4

Marcony Pizza

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Marcony Pizza

25–40 min

4.4

Smok-Haus of Hicksville

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Smok-Haus of Hicksville

60–75 min

• $

4.4

Organic Krush Woodbury

65–80 min

• $$$

4.6

Brooklyn Fish & Chicken

40–55 min

4.5

Lake Grove Diner

70–85 min

• $

4.6

3 Sons Deli & Catering

60–75 min

• $

4.8

Aji 53 (Bayshore)

10–25 min

4.7

Target (Bay Shore)

35–55 min

• $$

4.7

TCBY (1955 Jericho Tpke)

45–60 min

4.6

Chop Shop Bar & Grill

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Chop Shop Bar & Grill

60–75 min

• $

4.5

Local Burger Co. - Bayshore

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Local Burger Co. - Bayshore

10–25 min

4.7

Golden Chicken

10–25 min

• $$

New

Crostini Pizza on Broadway

55–70 min

• $

4.7

Raimos of Amityville

50–65 min

• $$

4.8

Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

2 Offers Available

Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

20–35 min

• $

4.4

Lorenzo's Pizza - St James

65–80 min

• $

4.6

Lucky Clucker

10–25 min

4.5

European Republic - Huntington

65–80 min

• $

4.8

Nonna's Pizzeria

55–70 min

• $

4.7

Pizza Corner - Medford

2 Offers Available

Pizza Corner - Medford

70–85 min

• $

4.5

Mamma Lombardis

70–85 min

• $

4.5

Galanga

30–50 min

•

$0 Delivery Fee

• $$

4.6

Cara Mia

65–80 min

4.7

Zio’s Casa Di Dolce

65–80 min

New

sweetFrog (5640 Sunrise Hwy)

30–45 min

• $$

4.7

Applebee's (East Islip)

25–40 min

• $$

4.3

The Good Life

55–70 min

• $

4.5

Pink's Vegan Diner (Merrick)

70–85 min

4.6

Oakdale Brew House

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Oakdale Brew House

40–55 min

4.7

Gino's Pizza of West Babylon

30–45 min

• $

4.6

QuickChek - Store 169

35–55 min

• $

4.2

La Espiguita Bakery - Brentwood

35–50 min

4.5

1683 SPORTS BAR & GRILLE

Top Offer • 20% off (Spend $20)

1683 SPORTS BAR & GRILLE

25–40 min

New

The Eagle's Nest Food & Smoothie Cafe

65–80 min

4.6

McDonald's® (107 Main St)

2 Offers Available

McDonald's® (107 Main St)

10–20 min

• $

4.5

Organic Krush Plainview

50–65 min

4.6

Papa's Pizza

Buy 1, get a free item

Papa's Pizza

55–70 min

• $

4.6

Food Bazaar (101 Wicks Rd)

Offers available

Food Bazaar (101 Wicks Rd)

55–75 min

4.6

Sayville Bait & Tackle

40–55 min

• $

4.8

Bobbique

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Bobbique

50–65 min

• $$

4.3

Greekrave

Free Item (Spend $30)

Greekrave

25–40 min

• $

4.6

Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace (Smithtown)

65–80 min

• $

5.0

Sunrise Diner

60–75 min

• $$

4.8

Blue Angel Diner

65–80 min

• $

4.6

Pizzaiola

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Pizzaiola

30–45 min

• $

4.5

Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

65–80 min

4.6

Buttercooky Bakery (495 New York Ave)

65–80 min

• $

4.5

American Standard - Whiskey Bar & Grill (W Main St)

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

American Standard - Whiskey Bar & Grill (W Main St)

15–30 min

4.4

Bare Naked Bakery

60–75 min

4.8

Andersen's Deli - BBQ - Catering

55–70 min

• $

4.7

Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace North Babylon

Offers available

Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace North Babylon

45–65 min

4.7

BEER KING

Spend $15, Save $3

BEER KING

30–50 min

• $

4.8

Chefs of New York - East Northport

65–80 min

• $$

4.7

Karvers Grille

2 Offers Available

Karvers Grille

50–65 min

• $

4.6

Massapequa Diner

55–70 min

• $

4.6

Scoops & Cones Cafe

65–80 min

New

Emilia's Bakehouse - E Northport

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Emilia's Bakehouse - E Northport

60–75 min

4.8

Island Bakery & Desserts

65–80 min

4.8

The Dark Horse Tavern

55–70 min

• $

4.6

Made by Lilis

20–35 min

4.7

Tango Argentinian Steakhouse

40–55 min

• $$$

4.6

Dix Hills Diner

40–55 min

• $$

4.8

Domino's (55 3rd Ave)

Top Offer • Free Item (Spend $9)

Domino's (55 3rd Ave)

15–35 min

•

$1.49 Delivery Fee

• $

4.5

South Bay Diner - Lindenhurst

30–45 min

• $

4.5

Patrizia's of Long Island (Hauppauge)

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Patrizia's of Long Island (Hauppauge)

50–65 min

• $

4.6

The 3rd Rail

65–80 min

• $$

4.5

Mario’s Pizzeria (Commack)

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Mario’s Pizzeria (Commack)

45–60 min

• $

4.6

Burger King (335 Montauk Highway)

2 Offers Available

Burger King (335 Montauk Highway)

10–20 min

• $

4.5

Roadtrip

15–30 min

New

Tropical Smoothie Cafe - Bay Shore Commons

2 Offers Available

Tropical Smoothie Cafe - Bay Shore Commons

10–25 min

• $

4.7

Panera (1701 Sunrise Highway )

10–25 min

• $

4.7

Golden Globe Diner

65–80 min

• $$

4.7

The Burger (17)

50–65 min

4.6

Rustic Root

60–75 min

• $

4.1

YoGoMania

45–60 min

• $

4.5

Babylon Burger Bar

25–40 min

• $

4.6

Bango - Bay Shore

3 Offers Available

Bango - Bay Shore

10–20 min

• $

4.7

Alpine Pastry Shoppe

65–80 min

4.7

Five Guys (1701 Sunrise Hwy.) NY - 1767

10–25 min

• $

4.7

Emma's Deli

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Emma's Deli

25–40 min

• $$

4.8

Amore Pizza

70–85 min

4.7

Lighthouse Diner

65–80 min

• $

4.5

Munchies To Your Door

3 Offers Available

Munchies To Your Door

65–80 min

• $

4.3

Friendly's (50 Montauk Highway)

25–40 min

• $

4.5

The Villager

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

The Villager

25–40 min

4.5

Amore Pizzeria & Fine Food

35–55 min

•

$2 Delivery Fee

• $

4.3

Momo’s (Union Ave)

50–65 min

• $

4.6

Calda Pizzeria & Restaurant (Massapequa)

65–80 min

• $

4.7

Umberto's of Sayville

40–55 min

4.6

Baskin-Robbins (529 E. Main St)

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Baskin-Robbins (529 E. Main St)

10–25 min

• $

4.3

Coliseum Kitchen & Caterers

55–70 min

• $

4.6

Suburban Eats

55–70 min

• $

4.4

Aegean Cafe

30–45 min

• $

4.8

Mary Carroll’s

25–40 min

• $$

4.6

Canz Bar & Grill Bohemia

30–45 min

• $

4.6

Joe's Pizza & Pasta

55–70 min

• $

4.7

Vinardos Pizza - Suffolk

35–50 min

• $$

4.2

Buffalo Wild Wings (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Buffalo Wild Wings (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

20–35 min

• $$

4.2

Cafe Gio

30–45 min

4.7

Conviction Chicken and Wings (326 - Farmingville, NY)

75–90 min

• $

4.5

Vespa Italian Kitchen & Bar

50–65 min

4.8

Vincent’s Steakhouse

65–80 min

4.5

Buster's American Kitchen (Islandia)

Free Item (Spend $35)

Buster's American Kitchen (Islandia)

45–60 min

• $$

4.5

Captree Gourmet Deli

15–30 min

• $

4.7

The Pizza Peddler 05/22 (22 1st Avenue)

35–50 min

New

Gregorys Coffee

30–45 min

4.7

Se-port deli

65–80 min

• $

4.8

Umberto's of Bellmore

85–100 min

• $

4.6

The Harp & Hound

20–35 min

• $$

5.0

Amity Ales

45–60 min

4.6

Patrizia of Long Island

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Patrizia of Long Island

65–80 min

• $

4.4

The Dirty Cheesecake (1160 Deer Park Avenue)

20–35 min

4.6

Checkers Drive-In (1825 Brentwood Road)

25–40 min

• $$

4.4

Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille (Bayshore)

10–25 min

4.3

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill (4005 Jericho Tpke)

$0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill (4005 Jericho Tpke)

45–60 min

• $

4.4

Strong Island Ice Cream

50–65 min

• $

4.7

Sweet Mama's (Northport)

60–75 min

• $

4.6

Hot Chicken Mama

40–55 min

• $

4.4

LIMANI GRILLE

40–55 min

3.9

Peter's Diner

35–50 min

• $

4.8

MB Pizzeria & Restaurant

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

MB Pizzeria & Restaurant

35–50 min

• $

4.4

The Local

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

The Local

30–45 min

4.7

Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

55–70 min

4.4

Burgerology (Massapequa)

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Burgerology (Massapequa)

65–80 min

• $

4.4

Pita & Pizza - Brentwood

30–45 min

4.4

Stony Brook Pizza

70–85 min

4.6

Pulcinella Neapolitan Restaurant

60–75 min

• $

4.6

Mann’s Homemade Ice Cream

35–50 min

New

Cream Bakery

60–75 min

• $

4.7

Gianna's Pizzeria

65–80 min

4.5

Bay Shore Deli & Grocery

10–25 min

• $

4.6

Salpino Italian Market

70–85 min

4.7

Nautilus Diner

50–65 min

4.6

Mario's Pizzeria (Syosset)

65–80 min

• $

4.7

PetSmart (North Babylon)

Offers available

PetSmart (North Babylon)

35–55 min

• $$

5.0

Cosmos Burgers & Creamery

25–40 min

4.4

Sweet Karma Desserts (136 Manetto Hill Rd)

65–80 min

• $

4.6

Simply Greek

55–70 min

• $$$

4.8

Emilio's Pizzeria & Ristorante

45–60 min

• $$

4.5

Sweet Surrender Bake House (Wantagh Avenue)

60–75 min

• $

4.8

Roast Sandwich House (Melville)

65–80 min

• $

4.7

Caffe Amici

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Caffe Amici

65–80 min

4.6

Gino's of Kings Park

60–75 min

4.7

Golden Bridge Deli

40–55 min

• $$

4.6

Dave & Buster's (Islandia)

Free Item (Spend $35)

Dave & Buster's (Islandia)

45–60 min

• $$

4.5

Denny's (255 Centereach Mall)

70–85 min

• $$

4.3

The Purple Elephant

60–75 min

4.9

Holbrook Diner

50–65 min

• $

4.6

Jimmy's Pizza

60–75 min

4.9

White Castle (265 Broad Hollow Rd.)

35–50 min

• $

4.5

Lili's Dessert Lounge (1160 Deer Park Avenue)

20–35 min

4.6

Prime Burger Bar

50–65 min

• $

4.4

Subway (1735 Union Blvd)

10–20 min

• $

4.5

Rust & Gold - Gerard Street

65–80 min

4.7

Milano Bean Cafe - Bay Shore

10–20 min

• $$

4.6

Millennium Diner

55–70 min

• $$

4.6

The Worst Cookie Company & Smoothie Cafe

65–80 min

• $

4.7

Simply Greekalicious

65–80 min

• $

4.7

Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

Top Offer • Spend $30, Save $8

Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

65–80 min

• $$

4.7

Americano Pie Bar

20–35 min

• $

4.6

Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

45–60 min

4.7

Main Street Deli

55–70 min

• $

4.5

Zest

Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Zest

20–35 min

4.7

Richie's Pizza

40–55 min

• $

4.6

Mooney pond deli

60–75 min

• $

4.8

Dortoni Bakery & Cafe

40–55 min

4.7

Prime Wine & Liquor

55–75 min

5.0

Heritage Delicatessen

Spend $39, Save $3

Heritage Delicatessen

45–60 min

• $

4.6

Blue Waters Mediterranean Cuisine

Free Item (Spend $40)

Blue Waters Mediterranean Cuisine

70–85 min

4.9

Umberto's Plainview

65–80 min

4.8

Crack't (1100 Waverly Ave.)

Spend $15, Save $3

Crack't (1100 Waverly Ave.)

55–70 min

3.3

Carlo's Pizza of Holbrook

55–70 min

• $

4.2

California Pizza Kitchen (160 Walt Whitman Rd)

Spend $30, Save $5

California Pizza Kitchen (160 Walt Whitman Rd)

70–85 min

• $$

4.4

A&S Fine Foods

65–80 min

• $

4.6

CVS (480 Montauk Hwy)

10–30 min

• $

4.5

Sur Argentinian Steakhouse

70–85 min

• $$$

4.8

1100 Deli

10–25 min

• $

4.4

Henley's Village Tavern

20–35 min

• $$

4.6

Auntie Anne's (1701 Sunrise Highway)

15–30 min

• $

4.7

Popeyes - Bay Shore

2 Offers Available

Popeyes - Bay Shore

10–25 min

• $$

4.4

Qdoba Mexican Eats (331 E Main St)

10–25 min

• $

4.7

Aegean Grill

55–70 min

• $$

4.6

The Ice Cream Chick

60–75 min

• $

4.7

Seaqua Deli & Catering

2 Offers Available

Seaqua Deli & Catering

65–80 min

• $

4.8

SMALLCAKES COMMACK

35–50 min

New

Island Lake Diner

Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

Island Lake Diner

60–75 min

• $

4.6

Starbucks (Islip Village)

$0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

Starbucks (Islip Village)

10–25 min

• $

4.7

The Olympic Diner

25–40 min

• $

4.7

Mediterranean Express - Powered By The Greek

20–35 min

4.6

Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Krave It Pizza & Sandwich Joint

70–85 min

4.3

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

5% off (Spend $35)

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

10–25 min

• $$

4.8

Krinti Mediterranean Grill

60–75 min

• $$

4.7

Limani Taverna

65–80 min

4.2

Mozzarella's Pizza

50–65 min

4.6

Brentwood Market Deli

30–45 min

• $

5.0

Popeis Bethpage

65–80 min

• $$

4.8

Gino's Trattoria

50–65 min

• $$

3.1

Miller's Ale House (Deer Park)

2 Offers Available

Miller's Ale House (Deer Park)

35–50 min

• $$

4.4

Brightwaters Inn

Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

Brightwaters Inn

15–30 min

4.6

Fredos Pizza & Pasta

55–70 min

• $

4.5

Sweetwaters Coffee & Tea: West Main

50–65 min

• $

4.8

Prestano Bagel & Bakery

40–55 min

4.8