Skip to content

Pet Supplies Plus delivered to your door

Enter delivery address

Pet Supplies Plus Delivery & Locations in Shelbyville

Small Animal

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Oxbow Simple Rewards Apple and Banana Baked Treat (3 oz)

Kaytee Cool Crock, Large

Kaytee Clean & Cozy White Small Animal Pet Bedding

Kaytee High Corner Litter Pan, Purple

Oxbow Western Timothy & Orchard Grass Hay

Kaytee Chewbular Play Tube Medium

Oxbow Essentials Hamster and Gerbil Food

Kaytee Comfort Harness and Stretch Leash

Oxbow Enriched Life Timbells Chew For Rabbits, Count Of 2

Kaytee Silent Spinner Exercise Wheel, Small

Kaytee Healthy Toppings Papaya Treat For Small Animals

Kaytee Clear Water Bottle, 8 Ounces

Easy Clean Pine Bedding (88.18 lbs)

Kaytee Timothy Hay (6 lbs)

Kaytee Simple Sleeper Cozy Hammock

Cat

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Frontline Plus Flea Tick & Lice Killer For Cat (1.6 oz, 3 ct)

Tiki Cat Puka Puka Luau Grain Free Succulent Chicken in Chicken Consomme Canned Cat Food (2.8 oz)

Instinct Freeze Dried Raw Boost Mixers Grain Free Digestive Health Recipe Wet Cat Food Topper By Nature's Variety (5.5 oz)

Nature's Miracle New Stain and Odor Remover Formula Spray For Cats (2 lbs)

Purina Friskies Dry Cat Food Surfin & Turfin Favorites (chicken, ocean whitefish, salmon,fillet mignon)

Pet-Ag Kitten Milk Replacer (11 oz)

Ourpets Pet Shuttle Cardboard Carrier

Play On Flea Comb

Dr. Elsey's Ultra Scoopable Multi-Cat Litter (40 lbs)

Play On Cat Furniture Scratching Post

Pet Supplies Plus Cat Laser Toy (4 ct)

Loving Pets Fish Bella Bowl For Cat (X-Small/Lilac)

Petsafe Scoopfree Disposable Crystal Litter Tray Refill (blue)

Feline Pine Original Cat Litter

Costal Lil Pals Adjustable Breakaway Kitten Collar, 5/16-in x 6-8-in, Pink

Trending products

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Dr. Elsey's Ultra Scoopable Multi-Cat Litter (40 lbs)

Oxbow Western Timothy & Orchard Grass Hay

Blue Buffalo Life Protection Natural Adult Dog Food, Chicken -Brown Rice (15 lbs)

Purina Pro Plan Pate Gravy Wet Cat Food

Kaytee Timothy Hay All Natural (3 lbs)

Vet's Best Flea & Tick Home Spray For Dogs (32 fl oz)

Feline Pine Original Cat Litter

Greenies Pill Pockets Chicken Flavor (7.9 oz)

Arm & Hammer Cat Litter Deodorizer With Baking Soda (1.88 lbs)

Oxbow Animal Health Western Timothy Hay For Rabbits & Small Animals (40 oz)

Arm & Hammer Daily Litter Fragrance Booster Multi Cat Strength

Pedigree Dentastix Original With Real Chicken Treats For Small Dogs (5.8 oz)

Kaytee Fortindiet Pro Health Guinea Pig Food (5 lbs)

Freshpet Vital Balanced Nutrition Chicken Dog Food (2 lbs)

Lennox Natural Pig Ears (1 ear)

Dog

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Nylabone Healthy Edibles Chew Treats Puppy Starter Kit (2.2 oz)

Play on Dog Pillow (navy blue)

Kurgo Black and Orange Tether

Play On Single Door Dog Crate, Xs, Black

Coastal Li'l Pals Dog Leash, X-Small - 3/8" X 6', Black

Multipet Lamb Chop Plush Dog Toy (3.2 oz)

Earth Rated Unscented Poop Bags (120 ct)

Good 'N' Fun Healthy Hide Triple Flavor Kabobs Dog Snacks

Ice Melt Down Ice Melter, 8 Pounds

Victor Classic Hi-Pro Plus Dry Dog Food

Hill's Science Diet Tender Turkey & Rice Stew Sensitive Stomach & Skin Dog Food

Beneful Purina Chopped Blends Adult Dog Food Variety pack (12 ct)

Play On Tie-Out Cable For Dogs, Small

Play on Stainless Steel Dog Bowl

Play On Bow Tie, Purple Plaid, One Size

Fish

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Tetra Aquasafe Plus Aquarium Water Conditioner and Dechlorinator (8.45 fl oz)

Fins First Aquatic Aquarium Heater, 200 Watt

All-Glass Clear Silicone Aquarium Sealant (3 oz)

Tetra Tetropro Goldfish Crisps Fish Food Flakes (7.9 oz)

Penn-Plax Skull Grazer Aquarium Ornament

Aqueon Cartridge For Mini Bowfront

Aqueon Standard Glass Rectangle Aquarium Clear Silicone (black)

Fins First Airline Tubing Clear, 8 Feet

Pondcare Accu-Clear Pond Clarifier ( large)

Tetra Ht10 Submersible Heaters (1 ct)

Mag-Float Aquarium Cleaner (small)

Penn Plax Pro Balance 7-day Betta Blocks Fish Food ( large)

Marina Black Decorative Aquarium Gravel - 1 Pound

Fluval Biomax Filter Media ( large)

Aqueon LED MiniBow™ Kit with SmartClean™ Technology, Black, 5 Gallon

Best sellers

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Purina Friskies Dry Cat Food Surfin & Turfin Favorites (chicken, ocean whitefish, salmon,fillet mignon)

Blue Buffalo Dinner With Garden Vegetables Wet Dog Food, Chicken (12.5 oz)

Hill's Science Diet Tender Turkey & Rice Stew Sensitive Stomach & Skin Dog Food

Good 'N' Fun Triple Flavor Kabobs Dog Treats

Pet-Ag Kitten Milk Replacer (11 oz)

Greenies Original Teenie Dental Dog Treats (43 ct)

Tiki Cat Soft & Chewy Cat Treats (tuna)

Meow Mix Original Choice Dry Cat Food (3.15 lbs)

Purina One Chicken & Rice Formula Adult Dog Food (8 lbs)

Blue Buffalo Natural Adult Wet Dog Food (chicken-beef )

Purina Tidy Cats 24/7 Performance Clumping Multiple Cat Litter

Purina Classic Ground Chicken & Brown Rice Dog Food

Good 'N' Fun Healthy Hide Triple Flavor Kabobs Dog Snacks

Freshpet Vital Complete Meals Grain-Free Beef & Lamb Fresh Dog Food

Blue Buffalo Blue's Stew Natural Country Chicken Stew Food For Dogs

Reptile

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

Mice to Go Large Frozen Rat (6.17 oz)

Fluker's Buffet Blend Aquatic Turtle Food

Mice to Go Small Mouse (1.5 oz, 6 ct)

Zoo Med Aspen Snake Bedding (8 qt)

Exo-Terra Daytime Heat Lamp 100w ( large)

Terrassic Reptile Décor Horn Succulent

ReptiFeast Reptifauna Springtail Culture

Zoo Med Hermit Crab Salt Water Conditioner

Exo Terra Faunarium, Medium

The Bug Company Prepackaged Mealworms Cup (100 ct)

Fluker's Freeze-Dried Crickets (1.2 oz)

Mice To Go Pinkie Mouse (8 pack)

8 ct • 2.4 oz

Zilla Jungle Mix Fir & Sphagnum Peat Moss (8 qt)

Zoo Med Reptile Deep Dome Lamp Fixture

Terrassic Reptile Décor Mandala Vine, Green

Bird

From Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

HARI Charcoal for Birds

Kaytee Forti-Diet Pro Health Cockatiel Food (5 lbs)

JW Pet Insight Clean Cup Feeder and Water Cup for Birds, Medium

Caitec Featherland Paradise Chewing Log Pet Toy (x-large/assorted)

Prevue Pet Products Square Top Parakeet Cage, Small

Lafeber's Nutri-Berries Parrot Food (3.25 lbs)

HARI Clay Cal Bentonite Clay Supplement for Birds

Kaytee Forti-Diet Pro Health Canary & Finch Food (2 lbs)

Caitec Cuddlebone Holder

Caitec 533 Medium Knots Block

Prevue Pet Triple Roof Cage

Lafeber's Nutri Berries Parrot Food, Tropical Fruit (10 oz)

HARI Oyster Shells for Birds

Brown's Tropical Carnival Gourmet Macaw Food (14 lbs)

Caitec Sure Lock Cup, 20 Ounces

1 Pet Supplies Plus location in Shelbyville

Pet Supplies Plus (Shelbyville)

$$ • 1605 E Michigan Rd, Shelbyville, IN 46176-1832

Javascript disabled

Javascript disabled

Javascript is needed to run Postmates. You can try enabling it or visiting the website with a browser that supports Javascript.