Skip to content

Michaels delivered to your door

Enter delivery address

Michaels Delivery & Locations in Bay Shore

Holidays & Seasonal Occasions

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Kinder Joy Treat + Toy Sweet Cream Topped With Cocoa Wafer Bites (0.7 oz)

18" Pine Tree In White Pot By Ashland

Ashland Ornament Hooks, Large , Green (120 ct)

Kikkerland Travel Nail Kit

Tumbler Protective Base By Ashland

4.5" Gold & Blue Hanukkah Candles, 45Ct. By Ashland

The Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington Headband

M&M's Chocolate Candies, Peanut (3.27 oz)

17" Happy Father'S Day Dad Dots Foil Balloon

Recollections Puffy Rainbow Star Stickers, Assorted (90 ct)

White Sunflower Stem By Ashland

17" Blue Happy Mother'S Day Artful Florals Foil Balloon

White Signature Mat By Studio Decor

PEZ Barbie Candy, Lemon-Grape-Strawberry (0.87 oz)

Ashland Unlit Pine Artificial Christmas Tree In Burlap Bag (36 in)

Art & Painting Supplies

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Strathmore 400 Series Wired Watercolor Paper Pad, White (12 ct)

Artist's Loft Super Value Canvas

Artist's Loft Desert Paint By Number Kit

Speedball Fabric Screen Printing Ink

Sharpie Fine Permanent Marker

Liquitex Basics Acrylic Paint, 4Oz.

Scrub Daddy Flextexture Ber (1.1 oz)

Artist's Loft Wood Tabletop Easels, 4" in

Strathmore 9 X 12 Inch Recycled Sketch Pad (780 g)

Artist's Loft Super Value Canvas, 9 in x 12 in, White (2 ct)

Artist's Loft Paint By Number Kit, 16 X 20 In (32 ct)

Speedball Fabric Screen Printing Ink

Pentel Hi-Poly Eraser 3ct

Liquitex Basics Acrylic Paint, 4Oz.

Scrub Daddy Sponge Daddy Dual Sided Sponge + Scrubber

Kids

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Crayola Assorted Bath Bombs

Crayola Washable Kid’s Paint Pot Set, Assorted (18 ct)

Creatology Primary Foam Sheets Value pack, 9" x 12", Assorted (40 ct)

Compound Kings Butter Cloudz Scented Slime, Assorted (4 pack)

4 ct • 3.53 oz

Snazaroo Face Paint, Silver (0.16 fl oz)

Creatology Unicorn Glow in the Dark Stickers (50 ct)

Crayola Alpha Pets Coloring Book

Kinetic Sand Scents, Ice Cream Treats Playset With 3 Colors Of All-Natural Scented Play Sand and 6 Serving Tools

Creatology Glow in the Dark Star Beads, 0.47" x 0.28" (280 ct)

Elf Pets Plushee Pals Mini Clip-On, Arctic Fox

STMT True2u Trendy Nail Art, Assorted

Crayola Glitter Washable Kids Paint (12.5 oz)

Creatology Adhesive Foam Sheets Value pack, 6" x 9", Primary (30 ct)

Compound Kings Passion Fruit Butter Cloudz Scented Slime

Snazaroo Face Paint, Turquoise (0.61 fl oz)

Best sellers

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Ashland Clear Crushed Glass (15.5 oz)

Sprite Soda, Lemon-Lime (20 fl oz)

Creme Savers Hard Candy, Strawberries and Creme (6.3 oz)

Glico Pocky Cookies & Cream Biscuit Sticks (1.41 oz)

Ashland Foam Female Head, White

Angie's Boom Chicka Pop Kettle Corn, Sweet & Salty (2.25 oz)

Bead Landing Lobster Clasps, 30 mm, Gold (4 ct)

Make Market Sublimation Short Sleeve Crew Neck Adult T-Shirt, Light Gray

Craft Smart Acrylic Paint, Olive Green (2 fl oz)

Cricut Cutting Mats, Multi (3 ct)

Cricut Glitter Iron-On Vinyl, Black

Celebrate It Velvet Ribbon, Black

Surebonder Clear Stik Full Size Glue Sticks, 4" x 0.43" (20 ct)

Ashland Glass Rose Vase, Clear

8" Rose Bundle By Ashland

Crafts & Hobbies

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Craft Smart Premium Clay Tool Set (blue) (4 ct)

Elmer's Washable Clear Glue

Decoart Ultimate Glow-In-The-Dark Paint

Celebrate It Velvet Ribbon, Black

Make Market Wooden Square Shadow Box, 5" X 5"

Make Market Triple Butter Soap Base

10" Unfinished Wooden Clock By Make Market

Fiebing's Leather Sheen

U.S. Shell Decorative Fishing Net, Brown

Eva Foam Roll By Make Market

Castin' Craft Castin Craft Resin Spray & Sealer, Clear (12.5 fl oz)

Make Market Crackling Wood Wicks, 12.7 cm (6 ct)

4.3" Unfinished Acrylic Keychains, 8Ct. By Make Market

DAP Plaster Of Paris For Wall & Ceiling Repairs, White

Gorilla Full Size Hot Glue Sticks (30 ct)

Home & Decor

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Foundry Candle Co. Candle

Celebrate It Woodgrain Charger, 13 inch, Gray

General Electric String-A-Long 100 Miniature Lights, Clear-Green

Assorted 10Oz. Western Enameled Metal Cup, 1Pc. By Fab Finds

Command Damage-Free Hanging Clear Large Crystal Hook

Valley Forge 8" X 12" U.S. Stick Flags, 2Ct.

Foundry Candle Co. Candle

Studio Décor Keller Easel, 14" x 7.5", Black

Ashland Led String Lights, Warm White

40Oz. Stainless Steel Insulated Tumbler By Ashland

Command Key Rail

Valley Forge Printed Polycotton United States Flag, 3' x 5'

Foundry Candle Co. Candle

4" Cactus Trinket Dish By Fab Finds

General Electric String-A-Long 100 Multicolored Miniature Lights, 20.6 ft

Trending products

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

M&M's Chocolate Candies, Peanut (3.27 oz)

Sprite Soda, Lemon-Lime (20 fl oz)

Celebrate It Gift Box, White

Haribo Goldbear Share Size Gummi Candy, Natural and Artificial Fruit (5 oz)

Lobster Clasps & Crimps By Bead Landing

Cricut Cutting Mats, Multi (3 ct)

Cricut Glitter Iron-On Vinyl, Black

Artist's Loft Acrylic Paints, Assorted (4.8 fl oz, 12 ct)

Stretch Magic Bead and Jewelry Cord, 16.4 ft

Stabilo Point 88 Fineliner Pen

Faber-Castell Unicorn Sensory pack Creativity For Kids Age 3+, Multi Color

Bead Landing Lobster Clasps, 30 mm, Gold (4 ct)

Cricut Smart Iron-On Glitter Heat-Transfer Vinyl

B2C Solar System Posters, 12" x 18" (2 ct)

Kikkerland Travel Nail Kit

DIY bracelets

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Stretch Magic Bead and Jewelry Cord, 16.4 ft

Rainbow Loom Friendship Mini Combo Bracelet Kit, Multicolour (2282 ct)

Creatology Stretchy Cord, 4Y+, White

Creatology Glow in the Dark Star Beads, 0.47" x 0.28" (280 ct)

Shell Beads By Bead Landing

Stretch Magic Bead & Jewelry Cord, 1mm X 25m, Clear

Bead Landing Matte Acrylic Craft Beads, Assorted

Stretch Magic Bead & Jewelry Cord, 40 ft, Assorted (8 ct)

Stretch Magic Sparkle Bead & Jewelry Cord

Stretch Magic Bead Jewelry Elastic Cord Line

Bead Landing Gold Alphabet Plastic Craft Beads, 7.4 mm x 8 mm (4.9 oz)

Creatology Plastic Bead Bracelets 6+ Months, Assorted (18 ct)

Stretch Magic Clear Bead & Jewelry Cord Set (4 ct)

Rainbow Loom Mega Combo Set Loomi-Pals & Sticker Pendants Bracelet Making Kit

Bead Landing Heart Acrylic Circle Craft Beads, 0.27" (4.2 oz)

Office Supplies

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Scotch Heavy Duty Shipping Packaging Tape Roll

Expo Chisel Tip Dry Erase Markers

17.7" Folding Lap Tray By Creatology

Fred Phony Bologna Sticky Notes

Assorted 5.5" Pink Novelty Pen, 1Pc. By Fab Finds

Tulip Assorted Rubber Bands

Energizer Max Aa Alkaline Batteries

Clorox To Go pack Disinfecting Wipes Fresh Scent Bleach-Free

Scotch Standard Bubbles Cushion Wrap

Expo Dry Erase Markers

Creatology Folding Lap Tray, Pink

Post-It 3" X 3" Super Sticky Notes, 5 Pack

Assorted Tinsel & Pom Pom Ball Point Pen By Fab Finds, 1Pc.

Fiskars Sewing Ruler, 3x18 Inch

Energizer Lithium 2025 3v Batteries

Party Supplies

From Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

Letter Gold Foil Balloon By Celebrate It

Celebrate It Gift Box, White

Celebrate It Draping Fabric, 35In x 20In, Black

Celebrate It Plastic Serving Bowl 5qt, Clear

Sprite Soda, Lemon-Lime (20 fl oz)

Celebrate It Paper Treat Bags, Large, White (12 ct)

Letter Gold Foil Balloon By Celebrate It

Celebrate It Gift Box, White

Celebrate It Plastic Table Cover, Black

Celebrate It Clear Plastic Kitchen Serving Bowl 24 oz

Claeys Wild Cherry Hard Candies (6 oz)

Celebrate It Treat Bags, Small, White-Gold

Letter Gold Foil Balloon By Celebrate It

Celebrate It Gift Box, White

Celebrate It By Plastic Table Cover

1 Michaels location in Bay Shore

Michaels (832 Sunrise Hwy)

$$ • 832 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706-5908

Javascript disabled

Javascript disabled

Javascript is needed to run Postmates. You can try enabling it or visiting the website with a browser that supports Javascript.