Name: Subway (404 Jay Street, 404A)
Address: 404 Jay Street, 404A, New York, NY, 11201, US
Telephone: +13479874850
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

Subway® Series

#23 The Hotshot Italiano
$8.49 • 88% (18)
Fuel your tastebuds’ need for fire with our Hotshot Italiano sandwich. Artisan Italian bread is topped with spicy pepperoni, Genoa salami, 2x provolone cheese, jalapeño peppers, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and an explosive finish of our MVP Parmesan Vinaigrette®.
#16 All-Pro Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki®
$10.39 • 97% (39)
Tackle your hunger with our All-Pro Sweet Onion Teriyaki sandwich. Enjoy a delicious combination of toasted Hearty Multigrain bread, tender grilled chicken strips marinated in our Sweet Onion Teriyaki sauce, 2x American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and red onions.
#1 The Philly
$10.49 • 71% (14)
The classic cheesesteak stacked with juicy steak and a double helping of American cheese toasted on Artisan Italian bread and topped with green peppers, red onions and mayo.
#30 The Beast
$11.99 • 100% (3)
The sandwich that makes hunger fear going to sleep every night — The Beast. This sub’s got pepperoni, salami, turkey, ham and roast beef all adding up to a whopping 1/2 lb of meat*. Add in 2x provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo, and top it all off with our MVP Vinaigrette and you get one beast of a sub. *½ lb of meat based on FL serving.
#18 The Ultimate B.M.T.®
$9.19 • 89% (29)
The Ultimate B.M.T.® is thoughtfully prepared with tender Genoa salami, spicy pepperoni, savory Black Forest ham, 2x provolone cheese, crisp lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and MVP Parmesan Vinaigrette® on Artisan Italian bread. Enjoy a sub made with love.
#20 Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch
$10.99 • 81% (22)
Treat yourself royally with our Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch sub. Combining tender rotisserie-style chicken, 2x melted Monterey cheddar cheese, hickory-smoked bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and our creamy Peppercorn Ranch all on Artisan Italian bread.
#15 Titan Turkey
$9.59 • 80% (10)
The Titan Turkey is big enough to stand up to any appetite! With 33% MORE* turkey, 2x provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and mayo all on our Artisan Italian bread. You’ll enjoy a meal fit for a titan! *33% more meat than Classic Sandwich portion.
#10 All-American Club®
$10.49
The American classic. Oven-roasted turkey, Black Forest ham, crisp bacon, and 2x American cheese with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and mayo. Served toasted on Artisan Italian bread.
#2 The Outlaw®
$10.49 • 100% (3)
Spicy, cheesy, smoky — this one’s got it all. Juicy steak meets double Pepper Jack cheese, with green peppers, red onions, and Baja Chipotle sauce toasted on Artisan Italian bread. Try not to fall head over heels.
#17 Garlic Roast Beef
$11.59
Our Garlic Roast Beef is an explosion of flavor in every bite! On soft Artisan Italian Bread is the combination of tender roast beef, 2x provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and finished with Roasted Garlic Aioli — unlocking a go-to option when hunger calls.
#99 Home Run Ham
$8.89
The Home Run Ham delivers heavy-hitting flavor every time. On top of Artisan Italian Bread is 33% MORE* ham, 2x provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and mayo — a delicious sub that leaves you feeling satisfied. *33% more meat than Classic Sandwich portion.
#11 Subway Club®
$10.79 • 100% (3)
Oven-roasted turkey, Black Forest ham, USDA Choice Roast Beef, 2x American cheese piled on Hearty Multigrain bread and topped with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and mayo. A club sandwich Subway® style.
#22 Spicy Nacho Chicken
$10.39 • 80% (5)
Fire up your taste buds with rotisserie-style chicken slathered in a double serving of our creamy NEW cheddar cheese sauce, topped with crisp green peppers, red onions and jalapeños. A spicy layer of Creamy Sriracha sauce and our crispy NEW SubKrunch™ are the finishing touches before it's toasted on our blazin' NEW, limited-time Ghost Pepper Bread for heat and flavor in every bite.
#34 Spicy Nacho Steak
$10.49
Face the heat head-on with shaved steak and a double serving of our NEW cheddar cheese sauce, topped with crisp green peppers, red onions and jalapeños. It's toasted on NEW, limited-time Ghost Pepper Bread and finished with our Creamy Sriracha sauce and crispy NEW SubKrunch™ to make every bite blazin' and delicious.
#24 Fiery Meatball
$9.79
Here to set your taste buds on fire, our classic meatballs and delicious marinara are kicked up to ten with a double serving of Pepper Jack cheese and jalapeños on a bed of spicy pepperoni. Topped with our Creamy Sriracha sauce and Parmesan cheese, it's toasted on NEW, limited-time Ghost Pepper bread for the final fiery touch.
#21 Honey Mustard BBQ Chicken
$10.39
Tap into flavor with juicy rotisserie-style chicken covered in melted Monterey Cheddar and topped with crisp lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and tangy pickles for the perfect crunch. Finish with a generous drizzle of sweet Honey Mustard and our hickory-smoked BBQ sauce, all served up toasted on Artisan Italian bread for a truly satisfying bite.
#31 Cheesy Garlic Steak
$10.49
Get ready to savor every bite of this garlicky delight, with shaved steak smothered in a double serving of our creamy NEW cheddar cheese sauce, with crisp green peppers, red onions, a flavorful kick of Roasted Garlic Aioli and a sprinkling of savory NEW SubKrunch™. Stacked generously and toasted on Artisan Italian bread, this sub will leave you craving seconds.
#6 The Boss
$9.79 • 100% (5)
It’s the mother of all meatball subs. Juicy meatballs drenched in marinara sauce with slices of pepperoni and provolone. Sprinkled with parmesan and served toasted on Italian Herbs & Cheese bread.

Subway (404 Jay Street, 404A)

Get it delivered to your door.

Featured items

Subway® Series

Classic Sandwiches

Sidekicks

No Bready Bowls®

Wraps

Breakfast

Salads

Drinks

Snacks & Sides

Shareable Desserts