Oh My, Cookie Pie!
Get it delivered to your door.
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
Monday - Thursday
9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday
9:00 AM - 2:00 PM
Saturday
Signature Cookie Pies
- Chocolate Chip$5.00Iconic chocolate chip cookie loaded with chocolate chips and stuffed with rich chocolate ganache. Baked crispy on top and flowing on the inside with chocolate.Popular
- Sticky Bun$5.00Brown cookie stuffed with a whole cinnamon bun and topped with caramel pecan glaze.Popular
- PB & J Cookie Pie$5.00Peanut butter-brown sugar cookie stuffed with scratch-made berry jelly and topped with peanut butter streusel.
- Pink Kitty$5.50Brown sugar cookie sprinkled with dried cranberries and cherries, then stuffed with a cherry compote and topped with a paw print marshmallow.
- S'mores Cookie Pie$5.00Chocolate brown sugar cookie stuffed with gooey chocolate ganache and topped with graham crackers and house-made vanilla fluffy marshmallow. Your campfire dreams all in one cookie pie!
- Leprachan Cookie$5.00Just in time for St. Patrick's Day, this brown sugar cookie is dyed green. Stuffed with our homemade marshmallow and then finished with two lucky clover marshmallows
- Red Lava$5.00Red velvet cookie baked crunchy on top and overloaded with gooey red velvet fudge and topped with crispy red sprinkles.
- Apple Pie$5.00Brown sugar cookie stuffed with house-made cinnamon apple pie filling. Topped with cinnamon streusel.
- Unicorn$5.00Multicolored brown sugar cookie stuffed with birthday cake marshmallow. Topped with a sprinkled unicorn-shaped marshmallow.
- Love Strong Cookie$5.50Our signature "Cookie for a cause" features a birthday cake cookie with a gooey sprinkle lava center stuffed with scratch-made marshmallows. Then cookie with a confetti heart marshmallow.
This is a "Cookie for a Cause" and we donate a portion of sales to Joe DiMaggio Children's Hospital - Lemon Blueberry$5.00Brown sugar cookie loaded with dried blueberries and stuffed with tart Florida lemon curd. Topped with crunchy meringue pieces.Popular
- Mint Chocolate Chip$5.00Chocolate Chip cookie dyed green for St Pattys day and stuffed with gooey, mint chocolate fudge
- Chocolate Irish cream$5.00Rich chocolate cookie filled with Irish cream filling and topped with crunchy chocolate streusel
