Name: I Like Pie Bake Shop - Pasadena
Address: 38 South Raymond Avenue, Pasadena, CA, 91105, US
Telephone: +16263455959
Rating: 4.8

Sweet Jelly Jar

Chocolate Chip Chess Jelly Jar
$9.49 • 95% (21)
Our Chocolate Chip Chess pie takes a twist on a classic favorite with the chocolatey, gooey goodness of a warm cookie and brown sugar custard in our buttery, sweet crust and garnished with a dusting of powdered sugar, chocolate chips and an individual chocolate chip cookie.
Salted Caramel Banana Jelly Jar
$9.50 • 95% (44)
This is sweet + salty at its tastiest. Dig into a layer of ripe bananas, homemade pastry cream, and a dollop of salted caramel in our traditional crust. Topped with whip and salted toffee bits. (It’s OK to drool.)
Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Butter Pecan Ice Cream!
Key Lime Jelly Jar
$8.99 • 93% (30)
You know this one: classic key lime filling, salty sweet graham crust, and a must-have mound of fresh whipped cream. Tart, creamy and here year-round thanks to customer pleas.
Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Ube Coconut Ice Cream!
Mixed Berry Jelly Jar
$8.99 • 100% (21)
Meet our most popular fruit pie. It’s sweet, tart, and brimming with blackberries, blueberries, raspberries, strawberries, and cherries. Baked in our traditional crust and topped with shortbread crumble.
Pairs perfectly with a scoop of Triple Berry Cream Cheese Ice Cream!
Cookie Butter Jelly Jar
$9.50 • 92% (26)
Baked in our signature graham cracker crust, this pie is layered with cookie butter cream cheese filling and topped with mounds of whipped cream and Speculoos cookie crumbs. Topped with a Speculoos cookie. A popular treat year-round!
Dutch Apple Jelly Jar
$9.99 • 100% (7)
Dutch Apple pie is one of the most nostalgic pies. Tart granny smith apples are baked in sweet cinnamon sugar, topped with the crunch of a cinnamon shortbread crumble, and garnished with an apple crust cookie.
Lemon Danish Jelly Jar
$9.99
One of ILP’s top three is back for the winter! Baked in our traditional pie crust and filled with lemon brown sugar custard, shortbread crumble, sweetened cream cheese and all topped with vanilla glaze. This pie is creamy with just the right touch of zing.
Turtle Brownie Jelly Jar
$9.99 • 100% (7)
Rich, decadent chocolate baked to perfection in our traditional crust and topped with sweet cream cheese, candied pecans, and a caramelized drizzle. This pie is perfect for chocolate lovers.
Banana Split Jelly Jar
$10.49
We baked all the flavors of Banana Split into a gorgeous pie! It’s graham cracker crust, vanilla pastry cream, candied pecans, fudge, bananas, pineapple cream cheese, with fresh whip and a cherry on top.
Boysenberry JJ
$9.99
Some customers wait all year for this! That luscious berry filling – fruity and floral – blanketed by a crumble of shortbread in our traditional crust. It’s been called “a revelation.” Taste for yourself.

I Like Pie Bake Shop - Pasadena

Get it delivered to your door.

Featured items

Sweet Jelly Jar

Hand Pies

Savory Pies

Vegan Pies

Gluten Free Pies

Ice Cream

I Like Pie Digital Gift Cards

Beverages