Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side
4.8 x (260+) • Bakery • Gluten Free • Cupcakes • Gluten Free Friendly • Desserts • $$ • Info
x Delivered by store staff
x Delivery unavailable
2325 Broadway
Get it delivered to your door.
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Monday - Wednesday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Thursday - Friday
10:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Saturday
11:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Featured items
Halloween
- Fall for Dessert 25-Pack$41.00Our bestselling fall flavors, back for a limited time! Inspired by classic Thanksgiving desserts, these bite-size treats will make your next dinner party the talk of the town. And the best part—there's no need to choose just one dessert. We make them small, so you can try them all!
Flavors Included
5x Chocolate Red Velvet Crunch
4x Caramel Apple Pie
4x Chocolate Raspberry
4x Fudge Brownie
4x Pumpkin Pie
4x Chocolate Cookie Cheesecake - Monster Mash 25-Pack$41.00LIMITED TIME ONLY! The Monster Mash will catch on in a flash, featuring six handcrafted Halloween flavors.
Flavors Included
5 x Spooky Tie Dye
4 x Bear-ied Alive
4 x Eyeball
4 x Green Goblin
4 x Midnight Munchies
4 x Fudge Brownie - Hocus Pocus 50-Pack$74.00Conjure up some cupcake magic! This 50-Pack is the perfect centerpiece for Halloween parties and events, with 16 delicious flavors.
Flavors Included
7 x Midnight Munchies
6 x Fudge Brownie
5 x Spooky Tie-Dye
4 x Bear-ied Alive
4 x Green Goblin
4 x Eyeball
2 x Cookie & Cream
2 x Peanut Butter & Jelly
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Tie-Dye
2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Mint Cookie
2 x Pumpkin Pie
2 x Chocolate Marshmallow - Graveyard Smash 100-Pack$139.00LIMITED TIME ONLY! Hosting a larger-than-life ghostly gathering? Trick-or-treat Halloween party guests to a 100-Pack Graveyard Smash, with 16 delicious flavors! Serve spooky seasonal treats from our limited-edition Halloween assortment and the bestselling Latest & Greatest assortment.
Flavors Included
14 x Midnight Munchies
12 x Fudge Brownie
10 x Spooky Tie-Dye
8 x Bear-ied Alive
8 x Green Goblin
8 x Eyeball
4 x Tie-Dye
4 x Cookie & Cream
4 x Peanut Butter & Jelly
4 x Cookie Dough
4 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
4 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
4 x Red Velvet
4 x Mint Cookie
4 x Pumpkin Pie
4 x Chocolate Marshmallow - Boo Crew 6-Pack (Bundle of 4)$45.00LIMITED TIME ONLY! Trick-or-treat your whole Boo Crew to spooky sweets this Halloween. These bundles of four 6-Packs are perfect for gifting, whether you want to treat your favorite (g)hostess, teacher, or lucky trick-or-treaters.
Each 6-Pack Includes:
1 x Bear-ied Alive
1 x Eyeball
1 x Green Goblin
1 x Midnight Munchies
1 x Spooky Tie Dye
1 x Fudge Brownie - Boo Crew 6-Pack$14.25"LIMITED TIME ONLY! Trick-or-treat your whole Boo Crew to spooky sweets this Halloween. These bundles of four 6-Packs are perfect for gifting, whether you want to treat your favorite (g)hostess, teacher, or lucky trick-or-treaters.
Each 6-Pack Includes:
1 x Bear-ied Alive
1 x Eyeball
1 x Green Goblin
1 x Midnight Munchies
1 x Spooky Tie Dye
1 x Fudge Brownie"
Cupcakes
- The Latest and Greatest Cupcakes$41.00 • 100% (9)Our best-seller! This cupcake pack is our go-to sampler for dessert lovers looking to try a little bit of everything. THE LATEST: our 3 seasonal cupcakes plus our monthly Mini of the Month! THE GREATEST: our 8 must-have original flavors!
Flavors Included
2 x Tie-Dye
2 x Cookie & Cream
2 x PB&J (contains nuts)
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Mint Cookie
2 x Fudge Brownie
2 x Pumpkin Pie
2 x Chocolate Marshmallow
3 x Cookies & Milk - Tie-Dye Cupcake 12-PK$22.00 • 100% (4)A dozen of Baked by Melissa’s signature Tie-Dye cupcakes! Each handcrafted with fluffy tie-dye cake, vanilla buttercream icing and rainbow sugar crystals on top.
- Fan Favorites 25 Pack$41.00Six exclusive flavors, handcrafted with love. This limited-edition 25-pack of cupcakes includes six beloved flavors including Cookie Butter Brownie, Blondie, and S’mores! Available for a limited time only.
Flavors Included
5 x Chocolate & Sprinkles
4 x Blondie
4 x Cookie Butter Brownie
4 x Electric Tie-Dye
4 x S'mores
4 x Vanilla & Sprinkles - All the Flavors 50 Pack$74.00This cupcake 50-Pack includes our limited edition Fan Favorites 25-Pack (filled with mouthwatering flavors like Cookie Butter Brownie, Blondie, and S’mores (stuffed with marshmallow fluff!) and our bestselling Latest & Greatest 25-Pack (with three seasonal flavors, eight OGs, and the Mini of the Month).
- Fan Favorite 6-Pack$14.25Flavors Included
1 x Chocolate & Sprinkles
1 x Blondie
1 x Cookie Butter Brownie
1 x Electric Tie-Dye
1 x S'mores
1 x Vanilla & Sprinkles
Pick Your Own
- Pick Your Flavors 25-Pack$46.00"All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 25 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month.
Your choice of:
Tie-Dye
Cookie & Cream
PB&J (contains nuts)
Cookie Dough
Triple Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate Chip Pancake
Red Velvet
Mint Cookie
Pumpkin Pie
Cookies & Milk
For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you." - Pick Your Flavors 12-Pack$25.50"All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 12 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month.
Your choice of:
Tie-Dye
Cookie & Cream
PB&J (contains nuts)
Cookie Dough
Triple Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate Chip Pancake
Red Velvet
Mint Cookie
Pumpkin Pie
Cookies & Milk
For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you."Popular - Pick Your Flavors 6-Pack$15.25"All of your favorite flavors, all in one place! Choose 6 bite-size treats from our ever-changing menu, featuring classic OG cupcakes and our mini of the month.
Your choice of:
Tie-Dye
Cookie & Cream
PB&J (contains nuts)
Cookie Dough
Triple Chocolate Fudge
Chocolate Chip Pancake
Red Velvet
Mint Cookie
Pumpkin Pie
Cookies & Milk
For Pick Your Flavor products, please indicate your preferred flavors and quantities. If none are provided, our stores will handpick a delicious selection for you."
Birthdays
- Happy Birthday Cupcakes & Candles$49.95 • 83% (6)Wish them a Happy Birthday with cupcakes & candles! This sweet gift comes fully equipped with 25 handcrafted, mini cupcakes in 12 flavors and our ‘Happy Birthday’ candle set! Cupcake flavors include our ever-changing Mini of the Month, 3 seasonal cupcake flavors and all 8 of Melissa's Original Greats.
Flavors Included
2 x Tie-Dye
2 x Cookie & Cream
2 x PB&J (contains nuts)
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Mint Cookie
2 x Fudge Brownie
2 x Pumpkin Pie
2 x Chocolate Marshmallow
3 x Cookies & Milk - Electric Tie Dye Layer Cake (Serv 8-12)$69.00*Stored frozen for transit. Bring to room temp 1 hour before serving*
Baked by Melissa takes the cake! A crazy delicious cake to take your celebration to the next level. Made with three layers of Melissa's signature Electric Vanilla Tie-Dye Cake, loads of vanilla buttercream icing, and tie-dye cake crumble topping. It's everything you know and love about Baked by Melissa, packed into a cake! - Groovy Birthday Gift Box 25-Pack$51.00 • 100% (5)The sweetest birthday gifts come in small packages! And you have options—this gift is best if you're looking for more variety! Choose one 25-Pack from any of the below assortments to send in our groovy Happy Birthday gift box. BEST FOR GIFTING A SPECIALTY ASSORTMENT!
- Groovy Birthday Gift Box 50-Pack$84.00Choose 2 assortment packs to fill your groovy birthday gift box! The best birthday present to send to celebrate any friend or family, near and far!
Specialty
- Vegan Latest & Greatest$54.00 • 100% (6)"Our best-selling cupcake assortment goes VEGAN! Curated by Melissa herself, the Vegan Latest & Greatest is your one-stop-shop for every vegan cupcake flavor on the menu. Each assortment includes 25 vegan cupcakes featuring six vegan cupcake flavors all handcrafted using the most delicious dairy-free vegan ingredients.
Flavors Included
5 x Vegan Strawberry
4 x Vegan Peanut Butter (contains nuts)
4 x Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip
4 x Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip
4 x Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut
4 x Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun"Contain Nuts - The Oh My Gluten Free Cupcakes$54.00Oh my, gluten free! Six wheatless, handcrafted gluten-free flavors that are fantastically rich and sweet. Now with NEW flavors, including Cookies & Cream, Marshmallow, Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Caramel.
All of our gluten free cupcakes & macarons are made in a separate facility.
Flavors Included
5 x Gluten Free Tie-Dye
4 x Gluten Free Red Velvet
4 x Gluten Free Marshmallow
4 x Gluten Free Cookies & Cream
4 x Gluten Free Cookie Dough
4 x Gluten Free Chocolate CaramelPopular
Parties
Add-Ons
What is the address of Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side in Manhattan?
Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side is located at: 2325 Broadway , New York
Is the menu for Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side available online?
Yes, you can access the menu for Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side online on Postmates. Follow the link to see the full menu available for delivery and pickup.
What are the most popular items on the Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side menu?
The most ordered items from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side are: Baker’s Dozen 12-PK, The Birthday 25-Pack Gift Box, Tie-Dye Cupcake 12-PK.
Does Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side offer delivery in Manhattan?
Yes, Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side offers delivery in Manhattan via Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see if you are within the Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side delivery radius, then place your order.
Can I get free delivery from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side?
Delivery fees for Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side vary. Just enter your delivery address to see the delivery fee for your location. You could always get free delivery from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side with Postmates Unlimited.
Can I pick up my order from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side?
Postmates offers pickup from many restaurants in your city. To see if you can pick up your order from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side, add items to your cart and look for the ‘pickup’ option at checkout.
Can I schedule a delivery order from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side?
Some restaurants on Postmates allow you to schedule a delivery to show up at your location when you want it. At checkout, look for the option to select a delivery time. If it’s there, that means you can schedule your delivery from Baked by Melissa - Upper West Side.
